Commenting your peers'

TO: 2008 INTAKE



Dear my beloved students,
This is the criteria and the grades that you might need to give comments on your classmates' writings.

Grades

A+: Outstanding (91 - 100%); A: Excellent (80 -90%),


B( 60 - 79%) , C (50 - 59%) , D (under 50%)

Criteria

I. Paragraph level (body paragraphs)


1. Grammar:


2. Vocabulary:


3. Development:


4. Ideas:


5. Unity, coherence:


II. Essay level


1. Introductory paragraph:


a. Thesis statement:


b. Ways of developing


2. Development ( How do the body paragraphs develop the controlling ideas stated in the thesis statement?)


3. Connection among the paragraphs ( how?)


a. Between the introduction and the others


b. Among the body paragraphs